Tuesday, July 14, 2009

Assault by Strangulation

Count 1 – not guilty 

Count 2  - not guilty

I’m pretty sure (quite confident, really) he was guilty, but there just wasn’t enough concrete evidence to prove the strangulation part.  For count 1 there was really nothing but the testimony of the victim and the defendant, so that one was easy to drop.  For the second count there were three 911 calls, some photographs of her reddened neck, and a doctor’s visit a couple days later with a complaint of pain.  In one of the 911 calls she’s screaming, “He choked the f---ing sh—out of me”, and another like comment, but that was really about all we had.  I just couldn’t say for sure what happened that night.

I became very upset late in deliberations, nearly in tears at one point.  Some of my fellow jurors had minds clamped completely shut from the start, and seemingly never heard a word that was said.  Many were automatically pleading not guilty without considering the evidence seriously enough, I thought.  The victim was very easy to hate – she had been arrested the night before her appearance in court, in front of her kids, in order to be forced to testify.  She was a train wreck on the stand - rude, cursing, belligerent.  But the trash talking in the jury room degenerated, and a group of four or five people were making up what could have happened, blasting the victim.  I heard at least three people say how she provoked him and had it coming.  Yes, I believe she provoked him but I will never think that for this she deserved to be strangled. 

Also, it was shocking how easily sidetracked the room would become.  People had forgotten testimony, even worse, they remembered things incorrectly.  I had copious notes and could correct most things, but it was exhausting.  We would consider a question, five people would blurt out personal stories about entirely different stuff, and soon we’d be talking about a really nice restaurant in Madison Valley.  I was banging my head on the table about five minutes into the process.

Shannon

1 comment:

  1. Friends of Shannon and DavidJuly 14, 2009 at 4:01 AM

    Should throw them both in jail. :)I have never been a fan of domestic violence. Sounds like a tough call.

    ReplyDelete