Monday, December 29, 2008

Why are science fair projects the worst?

10 reasons:

Pat has a science fair project due in a couple of weeks. (Reason 1: They span the holidays) With some struggle, we have a project that will involve burning different types of wood and measuring the heat output. (Reason 2: Teenage boys want the use of fire to be the cornerstone of whatever measurement is done.) We went to a local building supply and they conveniently had 3 foot 1x3 boards in maple, poplar and oak. Next, we needed to acquire a cheap aluminum pot that we use over a campfire. Since this wood is destined to be burned in a “controlled” experiment we had our handyman, Shawn, cut the boards into finger sized pieces. (Reason 3: They cost money.)

Of course, Pat is with his dad for much of the break so we needed to get down to work. (Reason 4: Everyone tends to procrastinate leading to “oh shit” moments as time gets short.) Projects involving fire are of course out-of-doors projects. This year, we are experiencing an unusually long winter storm (that means snow on the ground for more than 72 hours). Fortunately, it is supposed to get to 46° and only “sprinkles” today (and the next 5 days too).

The basic plan is to use a charcoal chimney to hold the fuel and aim the heat output at a pot of water. A charcoal chimney is used to light charcoal for backyard grills. It's a store-bought version of a coffee can with holes punched around top and bottom. The store-bought ones include a handle which is very useful and a platform to hold the fuel a couple of inches above the ground. This allows wadded-up newspaper to be tucked under the fuel as kindling. A couple of sheets of newspaper will get a couple of pounds of charcoal going so I hope it will get our wood burning as well. Above the chimney we want to place a pot of water. We will measure the water by weight and then measure the temperature rise in the water. Pat’s hypothesis is that denser wood will output more heat so we need to control either the weight or the volume. We made a mistake already and did not get good density measurements before we cut the wood into irregular pieces but I think we can recover from that and can use weight to approximate volume.

It seems the key to a manageable science fair project is: make sure you can measure something, don’t sweat all the inaccuracies and things you can’t control. (Reason 5: Parents, who do much of the work, are working without clear guidelines). In this case, we are going to lose a lot of energy output to the environment with no easy way to measure it. Oh well, I’m sure it is in the noise J. Another key is risk management: what happens if you don’t get usable data? (Reason 6: Risk of failure for the parents.) In this case, the major risk is probably that there is too much variance in the individual measurements for separate trials of the same material. No risk mitigation strategy yet.

Here are pictures from data gathering phase of the project (click the picture to see more):

I was surprised at how rapidly and how hot the wood burnt. A single trial took about 4 minutes from striking the match to reading final water temperature. I had hoped it would take more like 10 minutes. The first trial almost destroyed the thermometer and so we improvised a heat shield from aluminum foil. We measured initial wood weight, start-end water temperature, and final wood weight. We ignited the paper (with a teaspoon of vegetable oil) and left it going for 105 seconds and then placed the water over it and heated for 135 seconds (the balance of 4 minutes). Removed the water and put the remaining burning wood in a pot with a lid to extinguish.

The second set of trials led to some angst as the numbers were quite different (Reason 7: kids panic). We persevered however and at the end we had at least two close data points for each of the three samples, so that seems usable. Here is the raw data: (it was prettier when I created this table in word)

Trial Type Start Weight (grams) End Weight (grams) Weight Change (grams) Start Temp (°C) End Temp (°C) Temp Change (°C)
1 Oak 357 220 137 14.8 64.8 50
4 Oak 361 216 145 16.8 48.1 31.3
7 Oak 358 274 84 16.6 47.2 30.6
2 Maple 305 111 194 13.7 59 45.3
5 Maple 309 92 217 16.3 86 69.7
8 Maple 310 108 202 20.4 69.7 49.3
3 Poplar 248 55 193 16 59.2 43.2
6 Poplar 245 94 151 15 69.8 54.8
9 Poplar 244 42 202 19.2 72 52.8

 

There was 500 grams of water and the wood weights were chosen to be approximately equal volumes which we will compute indirectly but we at least qualitatively captured different “densities.” We made the casual observation that the Oak was much slower to light which is borne out in the data of net weight changes. Trials 1 and 5 seem suspicious and there is some other clutter in the data but there do seem to be some conclusions to draw. We will see what the student concludes (Reason 8: it is hard for engineer parents not to do the work).

The going-in hypothesis was that denser wood would burn hotter or more intensely. The data does not support this because the ignition rates were different. The lighter woods seem to catch faster and burn quicker and so over the timed interval gave up more heat. A longer interval might have controlled this better. A struggle I had early in the process was getting the student to be crisp about the hypothesis and how the experiment was going to test it and that shows up in this problem (Reason 9: good experiment design is hard, something that must be practiced).

Now we have the challenge of analysis and presentation which will also involve some planning, not a strength of 13-year-olds, particularly those that would prefer to play Xbox games. (Reason 10: teaching science is hard)

-david

 


2 comments:

  1. Enjoyed reading about the science project that you helped Patrick with. You definitely made that whole project run smoothly, you take the time to help and guide the kids. We all thank you and appreciate the effort you put into all this. Love, mom and dad

    ReplyDelete
  2. Friends of Shannon and DavidDecember 31, 2008 at 11:36 PM

    I knew from the very beginning of reading about this science project that it was written by you, David. You are going to have such "warm fuzzies" remembering this project with Patrick! Too bad you guys can\'t get some of the lumber from my yard. The neighbors and I all call it "tree droppings". We have an outdoor fire grill so we burn all the twigs and logs and roast marshmallows and hotdogs. I throw in as much as the grill thingie can fit and light it all with a big poof. Everyonce in awhile I singe my eyebrows and hair. Good luck with the project! Sounds like you guys are doing great!

    ReplyDelete